Gage Diamonds

Gage Diamonds

Rating 4.4

Customer Satisfaction: 8.8/10

Category: Jewelry Stores

** This website contains affiliate links, meaning we earn small commission if items are purchased, it helps us to support the maintenance of the website.


About Gage Diamonds

The family-owned business Gage Diamonds has been in operation for over 50 years, specializing in loose diamonds and engagement rings.

Gage Diamonds was founded in 1966 by brothers George and William Gage, and today the company is run by their son, Michael Gage. The store is located in the heart of downtown Boston, just steps from historic Faneuil Hall.

Is Gage Diamonds a Legit Company?

Yes, Gage Diamonds is a legit company that sells high-quality jewelry. The company is registered by the Better Business Bureau, and has +A rating, the site is safe to use so there’s no need for worries when buying from them. They offer a money-back satisfaction guarantee, and all their diamonds are ethically sourced.

Experiences & Complaints​

Gage Diamonds has 241+ reviews with an average rating of 4.4 stars on Trustpilot. Most clients note they are satisfied with the quality of Gage Diamonds jewelry, as well as the customer support.

Top complaints

Gage Diamonds is one of the best companies to buy diamonds from, with excellent customer service and high-quality products. However, there are some complaints that they don’t always deliver on time or fix any issues promptly which can be frustrating for customers.

There are disappointed customers as they have not received the earrings they ordered over three weeks ago.

“So I would rate this a 5 star. But the website was very confusing at first. I thought I was able to place my order and get this in 2 days, but it is pushed back a few weeks. I did do a customer set but the labeling on the top of the site is misleading. When I receive the piece. I may change this to a 5 star depending on quality.”

Top positive reviews

Overall, customers seem very pleased with their purchase from Gage Diamonds. According to reviews, Gage Diamonds sells quality jewelry only and takes care of its items. Summing up, we can say that buyers are generally satisfied with the price-quality ratio of jewelry from Gage Diamonds.

“I had the most incredible experience with Gage Diomonds. The Gage family has become our family and it is very clear they care about the quality of their work and the lives they impact”

“I just picked up my future wife’s engagement from FedEx and when I opened the beautiful packaging I was stunned at how amazing the ring looked. The diamond center stone is literally perfect, the sparkle, cut and clarity are just perfect. I’m not going to lie I wasn’t expecting that type of quality for what I paid but talk about a huge pleasant surprise. This is my second go round at marriage and the first engagement ring I purchased from a chain jewelry store (ryhmes with May) that I paid double what I did at Gage and was never happy with it.”

#1 Magdalena Three Stone Preset Engagement Ring

Magdalena Three Stone Preset Engagement Ring

The Magdalena Three Stone Preset Engagement Ring features a trio of brilliant round diamonds, each set in its own individual prong setting. The center diamond is slightly larger than the two side diamonds, and all three stones are set atop a slender band of 18K white gold.

So if you’re looking for an engagement ring that’s truly one-of-a-kind, then you need to check out the Magdalena Three Stone Preset Engagement Ring from Gage Diamonds.

#2 Hazel Halo Preset Engagement Ring

Hazel Halo Preset Engagement Ring from Gage Diamonds is a stunning ring that will make your special someone feel like they’re walking down the aisle in something truly unique.

This halo of diamonds around the center stone brilliantly reflects light, giving off an amazing sparkle and brilliance while also remaining elegant-style with its white gold setting – 14 karat for those who want to shine bright. The design is not flashy but pleasant and delicate.

#3 Women’s Diamond Wedding Bands

When looking for a diamond wedding band, women have plenty of options to choose from. Gage Diamonds offers gorgeous bands in different styles and colors that will suit any taste perfectly and will look naturally beautiful on your hand. Whether you prefer a simple band or something more elaborate, you will obviously find something you love at Gage Diamonds.

#4 Earrings

Earrings from Gage Diamonds are good enough both for casual wearing and special occasions. These earrings will be a great choice and a good investment in your confidence. Each pair of earrings is handcrafted. With a wide variety of styles to choose from, you’re sure to find the perfect pair of earrings from Gage Diamonds.

#4 Necklaces and Chains

Necklaces and Chains

There is a truly huge choice – from classic diamond solitaire pendants to trendy chokers and everything in between, they have a necklace or chain style to suit any taste. Moreover, with the wide range of price points, you can easily find something that fits your budget perfectly.

What is Gage Diamonds’ Financing?

Gage Diamonds offers financing options to help make your diamond purchase more affordable. With convenient monthly payments, you can spread the cost of your diamond over time. They offer two financing options:

1. The Gage Diamonds Credit Card

Purchases of $500 or more can be financed with the Gage Diamonds Credit Card. Convenient monthly payments make it easy to budget for your diamond purchase.

2. The Gage Diamonds Installment Plan

Purchases can be financed over a period of up to 24 months with the Gage Diamonds Installment Plan. With low monthly payments and no interest charges, this is an affordable way to pay for your diamond.

Gage Diamonds Pros & Cons


  • a wide variety of diamonds, making it easy to find the right one for you
  • free shipping on all orders over $500
  • money-back satisfaction guarantee, so you can return your purchase if you’re not happy with it
  • online chat service, where you can ask questions and get help from a diamond expert


  • some customers have complained that the customer service at Gage Diamonds is not very good
  • the prices at Gage Diamonds are higher than some other diamond retailers
  • the return policy at Gage Diamonds is not as generous as some other companies


Gage Diamonds are the highest quality diamonds on today’s market, and they usually come with a higher price tag. But if you want an expensive looking stone for your ring or something else valuable and charming then it is for sure worth considering. 

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does Gage Diamonds take to ship?

Usually it takes from 14 to 30 days to ship their products. In case you need your piece delivered by the certain date, it is best to contact Gage Diamonds directly to inquire about shipping times.

What is Gage Diamonds’ return policy?

Gage Diamonds offers a 30-day money back guarantee. If you’re not satisfied with your purchase for any reason, just contact their customer service team within thirty days of receiving it, and they’ll provide instructions on how to send it back.

How much do Gage Diamonds’ pieces of jewelry cost?

The most costly item from Gage Diamonds costs $50k and their least expensive piece typically ranges anywhere between 500-2000 dollars.