** This website contains affiliate links, meaning we earn small commission if items are purchased, it helps us to support the maintenance of the website.

Maiden Home vs Pottery Barn

We compared Maiden Home and Pottery Barn sofas on key criteria, based on customer reviews and our own analysis.


According to reviews, the Maiden Home Sullivan sofa is a bit deeper and longer than the Pottery Barn York sofa. However, some customers have found the Maiden Home’s cushions to be too firm.

Additionally, the back of the Sullivan sofa from Maiden Home isn’t high enough to support a head or a neck. Maybe it’s not the best sofa for watching TV or movies with a family.


When it comes to price, Maiden Home is slightly more expensive than Pottery Barn. However, shipping is already included in the price of Maiden Home furniture, while Pottery Barn shipping will cost you an additional $300.

For example, a Sullivan sofa from Maiden Home will cost you around $2600, while a similar sofa from Pottery Barn will set you back about $1700.


Maiden Home provides and offers a lifetime warranty on all of their furniture. If you are not satisfied with your purchase, they will pick up the piece and return it within 30 days. Pottery Barn, on the other hand, does not offer any furniture warranties.

Where are maiden Home and Pottery Barn sofas made?

Maiden Home and Pottery Barn sofas both are made in North Carolina.


If you’re looking for a quality sofa with a lifetime warranty, then Maiden Home is the better option. However, if you’re on a budget, Pottery Barn might be a better choice. Keep in mind that you’ll have to pay for shipping with Pottery Barn, while it’s included in the price of Maiden Home furniture.

Maiden Home

Pottery Barn

Rating 4.5
Rating 3.6

Made In: US

Made In: US

Free shipping: Yes

Free shipping: No

Shipping time: 6 weeks

Shipping time: 5-7 days

Warranty: Lifetime

Warranty: No warranties

Returns period: 30 days

Returns period: 30 days

Sofa prices: $2,225 – $3,850

Sofa prices: $1,199 – $3,999

Chair prices: $1,500 – 1,875

Chair prices: $499 – $5,000

Bed prices: $2,225 – $3,225

Bed prices: $349 – $5,299