Allmodern vs Wayfair: Which is the Better Choice?

** This website contains affiliate links, meaning we earn small commission if items are purchased, it helps us to support the maintenance of the website.

Allmodern vs Wayfair

AllModern is a modern specialty retail brand that is owned by Wayfair Inc. The company offers a streamlined experience with the best in contemporary furniture design.

AllModern sells furniture, appliances, and other items. Customers can enjoy a simplified shopping experience and find great pieces to add to their homes.

Wayfair is one of the largest online retailers for home furnishings, with a hugely impressive selection of items from many brands.

So, where is the best place to shop?


The prices for furniture at Wayfair and Allmodern vary greatly. Wayfair has a much wider range of prices, with some furniture items being very affordable and others being quite expensive.

When it comes to sofa prices, for example, the cheapest option at Wayfair is $265 while the cheapest option at Allmodern is $740.

However, the most expensive sofa at Wayfair is $22,599, while the most expensive sofa at Allmodern is only $6,599.

This shows that there is a greater range of prices at Wayfair, giving customers more options to choose from.

But, the price of the same model of sofa is similar on both sites. For example, the price of the Jones 86” Square Arm Sofa is $990.

What Do Customers Say About Allmodern

The delivery team is friendly and helpful, and the quality of the furniture is generally good. However, some customers have found that the colors of the furniture are not always as advertised and that the quality could be better in some cases:

“I purchased a stylish sofa from Allmodern. It was exactly what I was looking for at an affordable price, and the delivery team was also very friendly and helpful, carrying the sofa into the house even though it wasn’t required. But the color is not as advertised, the green color is actually more of a blue, but luckily I planned to repaint the room anyway so it wasn’t too big of a deal.”

“I bought a Gwyneth bookcase! Although, it’s a bit pricey, it looks really nice in my living room, and it was easy to assemble. The customer service was great, too. But the quality could have been better – there were some chipped shelves when the bookcase arrived, but fortunately for me, it was in an area I could hide.”

Some customers have said that the quality of the products they received was not as good as they expected, but overall, most customers are happy with the product and the return policy:

“We liked the look of our new Silva Geometric rug but it wasn’t very comfortable to walk on. It also didn’t work well in our office because it was too loud and didn’t absorb sound well. We ended up returning it and the process was easy thanks to their return policy.”

Allmodern Shipping

Allmodern offers a very reasonable and straightforward shipping policy. Shipping rates are based on the order amount, with free shipping available for orders over $35, and only $4,99 for orders under $35.

There are also no hidden charges or fees, which is always great to see. Additionally, customers have the option to send their orders to multiple addresses, which can be a real-time-saver.

All in all, it’s clear that Allmodern puts its customers first when it comes to shipping.

Allmodern Return Policy

Allmodern has a pretty generous return policy – as long as you return an item within 30 days of delivery and it’s in original condition, you can either get a refund or store credit. There are some items that can’t be returned though, including clearance items, gift cards, personalized items, and open box items.

If you’re returning a large appliance, make sure to inspect it before installation because once it’s installed, it can’t be returned. And finally, if you have a registry item from Allmodern, you can return it for store credit up to 90 days after the event.

Allmodern Pros & Cons


  • Free shipping on orders over $35
  • One-stop shop for all things modern
  • Friendly and helpful delivery team
  • Straightforward shipping policy
  • Generous return policy


  • Colors of furniture are not always as advertised
  • Can’t return installed appliances
  • Registry items can only be returned for store credit up to 90 days after the event

What Do Customers Say About Wayfair

Customers who have purchased items from Wayfair generally speak highly of the company’s customer service. Many reviewers say that the customer service team is quick to respond to questions and concerns and that they are always willing to help solve any problems:

“The Wayfair bedroom set I purchased arrived on time and met my expectations. The customer service was great, they were quick to answer my questions and help me solve any problems I had.”

“We purchased our throw rugs from Wayfair. The quality wasn’t the best, but the customer service was amazing. They offer a refund if you are not satisfied. Recommend!”

There have been some complaints about the quality of some of the products:

“Their customer service is excellent, and delivery is always fast and on time. A few items I have ordered have had defects, but that is not the fault of Wayfair since they do not manufacture the furniture. I would recommend them to others because they are always willing to resolve any issues and find solutions for their customers.”

Wayfair Shipping

Most orders from Wayfair come with free shipping. Orders that are under $35 have a flat shipping rate of $4,99, and orders over $35 qualify for free shipping.

You can tell if an item qualifies for free shipping by looking for the “FREE Shipping” message underneath the price on the product page. In some cases, additional shipping charges may apply for orders going to Alaska, Hawaii, or U.S. Territories

Wayfair offers different shipping speeds and types to ensure that your product arrives safely and on time. For smaller items (less than 150 lbs), they use UPS or FedEx delivery services and for larger items, they use specialized carriers. You can find more information about each option on the product page or in your cart. Usually, large items take one to three weeks for delivery.

Wayfair Return Policy

If you’re not satisfied with your purchase from Wayfair, most items can be returned within 30 days of delivery. The item must be in its original condition, undamaged, and in its original packaging. There are a few items that cannot be returned, such as gift cards and personalized items.

Additionally, any delivery or assembly fees will not be refunded. Mattresses come with a 100-night free trial, so you can exchange them for a different one if you’re not satisfied.

Large appliances can also be returned within 30 days as long as it has not been installed and is in the original packaging. If you receive the wrong item or it arrives damaged, don’t accept the delivery and contact us so we can arrange for a replacement.

Wayfair Pros & Cons


  • Wide variety of furniture
  • Different shipping speeds and types to ensure product arrives safely and on time
  • Free shipping on most orders
  • You can often find good deals and coupons for Wayfair products


  • No showrooms
  • Quality of some products may be poor


There are pros and cons to shopping at both AllModern and Wayfair.

AllModern offers a streamlined experience with the best of modern design, but Wayfair’s impressive selection of home furnishings from many brands may be more appealing to some shoppers.

The best place to shop depends on the shopper’s individual preferences.



Rating 2.6
Rating 4.1

Free shipping: No

Free shipping: No

Shipping time: 1-10 days

Shipping time: 1-3 weeks

Warranty: 2 years

Warranty: One year

Returns period: 30 days

Returns period: 30 days

Sofa prices: $740 – $6,599

Sofa prices: $265-$22,599

Chair prices: $182-$2,700

Chair prices: $520-$12,299

Bed prices: $468-$4,378

Bed prices: $550-$24,750